As Material and Means of Violations
Iman Khamas
Occupation Watch Center (Baghdad)
It
is important to say at the beginning that there are many
psychological, social and cultural obstacles for Iraqi women to talk
openly about what they
actually went through inside the occupation prisons. The honor value
is the most sacred in Iraq, it is more important than the value of
life itself. We have to mention here the reasons why women do not want
to testify about different kinds of violations and abuses after they
are released from the occupation prisons. They refused to give their
names, photos, voices, even after they are concealed.
1-
"We do not want to go back to prison", this sentence was repeated by
four of the women prisoners we talked to, and a dozen of men. I one
incident, a female detainee gave us a testimony of many pages of what
she personally went through or what she heard of other women prisoners
after we promised not to mention her name. She spent 5 months in
prison, together with her brother. But the brother refused to give us
the papers, he grabbed them and tore them into pieces; "I do not want
her to go back there, neither me. I am the only man left in the
family, my brother was killed in the Iranian war, my mother is
paralyzed, I have two unmarried sisters, I have a wife and children to
support", he was furious, then he showed us a document that he had to
sign before he was released. The document says that if he was a
Baathist, he would not go back to the party, that he would inform
about any one who contacts him about it, or about any other party with
similar principles. The document also demanded that he would inform
about any one who works in the resistance, or have any thing to do
with it, that he knows of, that he should not go away of his house
more than 10 kilometers, otherwise he would not be released. If he
does not inform the occupation authorities about any movement he has
to do, or if he travels outside Iraq. Of course if the detainee does
not comply to any of these points, he would be arrested again.
2-
Unwillingness to talk openly about sexual harassment, for reasons
connected to the conception of the honor value in the Iraqi society
and family. A woman, or a man, would prefer to die rather than
jeopardizing the family reputation. For a woman to be sexually abused
is a shame on the family. A woman I met in Rusafa prison complex in
Baghdad refused to talk to me. She was spending her days fasting,
reading Quran and praying. She began to cry. Then she said if my
family knows about what happened to me, they would slaughter me. She
was in her sixties. We realized later that she was repeatedly raped by
many Iraqi militias. She gave us a letter to her family. She said "I
do not mind being killed, but first I want to tell the whole world
what the aggressors and the occupiers did to her, and clean my shame
in my own way".
3-
Many prisoners lost confidence in media, fact finding groups and human
rights organizations. They think that they work for the American
intelligence. One prisoner said I will not talk unless I am outside
Iraq….then I will say every thing.
4-
Some prisoners do not find any benefit in publishing their
testimonies. They find it political or media trading. They believe
that nothing can return their dignity, or to put things right in Iraq
again, after it is violated by the military occupation. One of the
people we met whose female relative was just released said, she does
not want to talk I do not want her to talk too. What are you going to
do to Iraq, how are you going to help, she is not important after we
lost Iraq, let her disappear or die…Amnesty International
representative was with us in that meeting. She accompanied us while
we were looking for another female prisoner who was recently released.
We were going from on house to another, she was hiding, and we knew
later that she was hiding her children in relative's houses for fear
of being hurt.
Testimonies
International Occupation Watch Center has already visited Rusapha
prison December 19, 2003. There were 13 of what the American
authorities call security inmates, a description given to political
prisoners arrested for information of being: Baathist, have some
relation to the resistance, finding weapons in his house. At many
times the informer's motives could be personal, or to get the reward
from the American authorities. One prisoner told the investigator that
99% of the informers are liars, they are simply after rewards. The
investigator replied we know that, it is among the hundred we find one
whom we want. When the prisoner asked but what about the 99 innocents,
"This is the game" the officer replied.
Reasons of arrests for the 13 women were:
1-
political or religious belief: mainly Baathist or Islamist, as in
Falloja for example.
2-confused accusations:
a-
funding the resistance
b-
Resistance
c-
anti occupation meetings
d-
family links with officials in the past regime: mothers, daughters, or
any relation with ex Baathists and resistance wanted by the occupation
authorities.
Arresting women as hostages, and putting pressure on the men using
their women are violations of the highest value in the Iraqi society
which is the honor value. Women for the occupying troops and their
intelligence became a means and of violation, contrary to Bush's
discourse to the international community that America occupied Iraq to
liberate the Iraqi women as part of its mission. In his electoral
program Bush confirmed his attitude of opposing any discrimination
against women, that beating a pregnant woman for example is considered
a violation to the woman's and the child's rights as well. According
to eye witnesses in Abu Graib there were women who gave birth to
children in side the occupation prisons. They were arrested while they
were pregnant. A woman who was arrested at the out skirts of Kerkook
has just given a birth to a baby 18 days ago, and was breast feeding
him. The American soldier threw the baby to his grandmother, and
arrested the mother while milk was running on her clothes.
3-malicious informers: a woman was arrested for example because her
schizophrenic sister informed against her together with her husband
and son.
Under
Occupation,
a monthly newspaper published by OWC, published in January a report on
these 13 women in Rusapha prison. OWC could not enter any other
prison, specially Abu Graib, because the occupation authorities did
not allow them, or any other human rights, or legal organization to
ask about any male or female prisoners who have no right to give power
of attorney to any lawyer. No one what ever his nationality is can
legally proceed with these cases. This is what OWC was told by the
American colonel who was responsible for the American prisons in Iraq,
Chuck Rayan, in December 2003.
Some
women prisoners were released , but arresting women did not stop. In
fact it increased in Abu Graib, the arresting campaign included
villagers in Falloja area, house raids continued, women of all ages
were arrested. A male prisoner told us that he saw with his own eyes a
very old woman, over 80, walking in the prison by a stick in Abu
Graib. OWC interviewed and documented a girl of 12 who was arrested
with her two sisters (19, 21 ys) and her mother (over 50) in the
airport prison in December.
OWC
met 5 women and many male prisoners, many refused to talk openly. Some
talked on condition of unanimity. They demanded that details like the
date and place of arrest or release are not mentioned for fear of
being recognized by the occupying authorities.
Witness A said she is willing to testify openly outside Iraq,
she was willing to talk to us too. A was arrested for 5 months.
One day in Sept. 2003, her house was raided by American armored
vehicles, tanks, and hummers which surrounded the neighborhood and
closed the street. Tens of heavily armed soldiers as if in a big
battle entered the house, they did not reply when I asked what they
wanted. They gathered the women in one place and took the men away.
They asked me about my name, when I gave it the translator grabbed my
hand and said this is a political target. Other soldiers were
searching the house. They took my books, my phd thesis, my CDs, and my
computer. They told me that they are going to take me with them for
few hours to ask some questions, a very quick investigation they said.
They arrested one of my relatives, and one of our neighbors who was a
diplomat, just because he was from the same province. I realized that
they were arresting me for my tribe, not for any thing else.
The
raid and arrest happened after I gave an interview to a foreign
newspaper, where I talked about the right of any Iraqi to join any NGO
even if it was working under Saddam. I suspect that my arrest has
something to do with this interview. They took me to (…) in the north
of Baghdad, in an area which is still under construction. They made it
their office. It was almost sun set. My eyes were tied. I entered a
place which I realized later that it was an unfinished house. They put
me in a room which they called (the cave). The window was closed with
bricks and the door with metal plates, I tried to find about the room
with my hands. There were three iron beds without mattress. I sat on
one of them. I heard something in the room, I was terrified, I thought
it was a snake. Something bit my foot finger, it hurt. I realized that
it was a rat. I pulled my feet and sat legs crossed on the bed. It was
not easy with all the springs. I began to read lines of Quran. I was
worried about my paralyzed mother and my sisters. But I was most
worried for my relative.
After a long time I asked where the investigation is, I thought they
were honest when they said that it will not take more than an hour. I
asked about any official in the facility, a voice answered (Shut
up). I tried again, this time I asked for the bathroom. The soldier
took me to an finished bathroom. The house was just a skeleton. I took
a deep breath; someone pulled me back to the dark cave. I searched the
ground for some thing to put on the bed. It was too hot to sit on the
iron bed. I found a piece of thick paper box. I flattened it and put
it on the bed. I asked again about the investigation, the answer came
through the closed door (Later, later ). I prayed on the bed. I tried
to sleep. I saw glimpses of light through the small holes in the
wall. It was dawn. I tried to find out about the noises, I realized
that there was a box filled with refuse and food remains and empty
juice cans. There were rats searching in it. One of them bit me
yesterday.
They
gave me a bottle of water and a piece of cookie. That was all I had
that day. It was too hot, I was sweating all day, I needed more water.
In the afternoon, the door was strongly opened, a woman was entered.
She was screaming hysterically of fear and darkness, and of rats. But
the most frightening thing for her was what will happen to her after
prison. She told me later that her schizophrenic sister gave false
information against her, her husband and her son, saying that they
hide weapons in the house. All were arrested although no weapons were
found. That woman was arrested for several months. Up till now, I do
not know if she is released or still in prison for false information
from a crazy woman.
In
the airport prison they took our clothes and gave us different ones.
They searched us and and took every thing we had. They called me for
investigation. The officer in the Army or the intelligence asked about
my name, religion, faction, work, and interests. He was interested in
discussing my ideas about women work in civil society. He liked my
logic, and said that he was talking to a civilized woman. I was glad ,
I thought I was going to be released soon. That was not what happened.
They showed me the place where I am staying in during my detention in
the airport prison.
In a
tent we were 20 women., ten of them were arrested for political
reasons. (she mentioned the names, some of them we have no idea where
they are now). The others had different charges.
Female tent was facing male tents. We
could see them. There were bathrooms made of wood. They do not reach
the ground, in fact there are at least 50 centimeters between the
ground and the wooden wall of the bathroom. Our feet and legs could be
seen when we go to the bathroom, which was very embarrassing and
opposite to our religion. One morning, female prisoner (S) who was an
old very respectable lady was having a bath when a woman soldier,
accompanied by many men soldiers, called her. (S) put the clothes on
her wet body, tied her hair, and run to the yard where she was called.
The woman soldier said we want to search you. It was a strange order
because she had nothing on apart from her prison dress. We realized
that they wanted to humiliate her. She was put between two soldiers,
her arms stretched vertically, her legs opened as wide as she could.
The woman soldier began to (search) her. She pinched her, pressed
parts of her body, opened her hair, pulled it strongly and searched it
severely, and then she hit the women between her legs. She repeated
this for four times, each time from one side. By then we were sure
that she was humiliating the woman in front the male prisoners. The
message was clear. These are your women in our hands, either you
confess or….
A
talked about another prisoner, Um Tai, the wife an ex official in the
presidency. She was arrested as a hostage to force her husband give
himself to them. She was over sixty, suffering from liver and kidney,
her husband was retired many years before the war. She was put in
solitary confinement; her tent had the size of one mattress. She was
not allowed to go to bathroom for two days. She was left without water
or food for 2 days. She had to use one corner of the room-mattress as
a bathroom.
Um
Tai talked about how male prisoners were tortured in Abu Graib. She
said they bring the naked prisoner, eyes tied, and tie him to the
bars, arms and legs stretched out like on a Cross. They begin to
torture him. They beat him, especially on the sensitive parts of his
body. They threaten them with military dogs; in one incident the dog
actually bit a prisoner from his thigh. The man fainted. In other
occasions, they force naked men to lie on ice blocks, some had heart
attacks.
A
also talked about the four sisters of Taha Yassin Ramadan, the ex
leadership member. They were cruelly tortured; we could hear their
screams filling the place. They let military dogs attack them. The
youngest sister went hysterical; she suggested many places that he
could possibly be in. They did not know where the brother is.
The
meeting with A took about four hours. She insisted not to give
any information about her identity. She talked about another prison
she was moved to, it is in Baghdad. There 3 rooms for 3 different
kinds of women prisoners. There were 56 women. The rooms give on an
open corridor. It was very cold. The cold drifts make it even worse.
There were windows near the roofs, but there was no glass on them.
Sickness hurt us. Stomach, colon, diarrhea, respiratory, colds, and
ear infections . We had to take cold baths, there was no hot water.
Even after water heaters were repaired, they were broken again in no
time because of overload. Even if there was hot water it was not
enough for the entire prisoner to wash their bodies and clothes . The
water was cut after a while, we had to put our wash on our beds to
dry. The food was bad, two meals a day. The first, at noon was a
handful of rice and some soup, beans, lentils, or eggplants. It was so
bad and greasy that we had diarrhea.
A
had whisper some thing in my ear,
although there was no one else in the room. One prisoner was raped 17
times by Iraqi police men to the knowledge of the American. We do not
know who she is, why she was imprisoned. She was not well, she kept
silent, and she was vomiting all the time. She was taken away; we do
not know anything about her.
A
now sits at home, does not go out at all. She thinks that her life is
ended, that there is no use in anything. She said that this is
globalization. It will take away all our values, beliefs, together
with our recourses, our land and our two rivers. (We heard stories of
sexual harassment by Iraqi police men from other women prisoners, and
also from men. One of the male prisoners gave us names of 3 Iraqi
women who were beaten in humiliating way. They had to lie on their
backs, legs up, and they were beaten on their feet).
A
sign on the head
A
gave us B's address. B was a fellow prisoner. She has a degree
in law, and she writes poetry. She said she wanted her story to be
heard by every body all over the world. An Amnesty International
representative, Jihan Al'alaily, accompanied us to visit her. It was
very difficult to find her. In every address we were given, we were
faced with angry reply, refusing to help us. When we met her at last,
she said that she knew A, that she loved her and actually wrote poems
about her. She said that A was a respectable and patient woman. B
said that she is willing to say every thing outside Iraq. Here I will
not say a word. Then, she put her head down, removed her hair and said
(Look). There was a big wound not yet healed. There was no hair in the
place. She was angry:" my money was stolen , my family is shattered
now, I am afraid for my children and for my self. I sent each one of
my children to a different place". We had to promise her that we are
not going to reveal her identity. She promised to tell us every thing
in the next day. Before we leave she said they forced me to stir a pot
filled with human excrements and petrol. I had to keep on stirring on
fire until it is dry. I had allergy because of that, I could not eat
for a long time. Now whenever I remember I feel sick and want to
through back. I was hand cuffed for 27 days. What do you want me to
say more.
Next
day she did not come to our appointment. She kept running away from
us. A man who knows her said : leave her alone, she is afraid and
worried about her family.
………
A
friend accompanied us to a relative house. He said that a woman ( C
)has just been released. AI representative was with us. A relative of
C received us at the gate. He apologized that she can not meet us. We
tried to convince him that we are not going to reveal any information
leading to her identity, that her testimony was very important to save
other women in prison. He promised to help and went inside . When he
came back he was even more obstinate, he said : All Iraq has gone,
what importance this woman has. Please leave us alone.
………….
D
who is Palestinian by origin was arrested by Iraqi police men. She was
beaten , tortured, and whipped, for no clear reason. Her brother said
she came back with torn clothes, that she was hearing screams of
another woman cruelly tortured. She knew that the other woman was
working as a secretary in the General Federation of Iraqi women. We
have already heard that Iftikhar Alsamara'I , the under secretary of
the Federation is arrested( she is released lately) . Which is strange
because Iftikhar herself went to the American directly after the war,
she introduced her self and told them everything about her identity.
They told her what do we need from an NGO woman. Go home . But she was
arrested all the same .
We
asked to meet D , her brother said no way. The Iraqi police
arrested her, and the American released her. We do not want to come
close to the bear. We heard later that she left Iraq where she lived
since 1948.
…….
Prisoner E's sister visited us asking for help. E was
arrested with her daughter , her son in law and a guest in their
house. The guest was released after 4 days, the daughter was also
released after 9 days, but E and the son in law are still in
prison. E was a member in the Baath party, we have information from
an ex prisoner that she is being beaten during the investigation, that
she was accused of helping the resistance. E's daughter told us
that after she was investigated and proved to be (innocent) the
officer who was responsible for the prison called her. On the way from
her cell to his office, the translator told her "you are going to see
the manager of this prison. He is going to ask you about how was it
inside the prison; whether you were tortured or not etc…If your
answers are negative you are going to be sent back to the cell, you
are not going to be released. If you say that every thing was okay you
will be released. Of course she said every thing was fine inside
prison, she had also to sign a paper saying that she is going to
cooperate with the occupation authorities if she hears or knows
anything useful she would inform them. Such a paper is signed by all
the prisoners we met who were released. E is still in jail.
………..
Male
Prisoners' Testimonies
A
friend of OWC has her son, who worked as a translator for the American
troops, arrested. She was waiting at the Abu Graib gate when a group
of prisoners was released. She tried to know some thing about her son.
One of the prisoner said sorry I do not know him, but he surprised her
by saying there is a very awful thing going on inside the prison, few
days ago, he added, the American forces lead a naked woman in front of
the men's tent, then they throw her in one of them. One of the
prisoner threw a blanket to cover her.
The
Iraqis have read a letter supposedly written by a woman prisoner in
Abu Graib. OWC has emailed a scan of this letter to American women
organization. The letter demanded that the brave and honest Iraqis
should clean their honor by bombing the Abu Graib prison, because
shameful things are going on inside, that female prisoners are being
sexually abused in many ways. The letter was signed by a woman called
Noor.
This
letter got suspicious reaction; many said it could be fake, just to
excite the Iraqi street. But any way there was much talk about female
prisoners' sexual abuse. A recently released male prisoner, F,
agreed to tell his information about women prisoners on condition of
anonymity. The stories F told us about women abuse are exemplary of
double abuse, he said we were sitting in the warm sun outside the tent
when a truck passed. There were three women in the truck. A colleague
put his head down and went back to the tent. I told him that it is sad
to see women prisoners; he told me that the women he just saw were his
mother and sister. He did not recognize the third.
F
recalls seeing the American soldiers leading a women in her thirties,
with torn clothes, almost naked, hands tied she was trying to cover
whatever part of her body was showing. One of the prisoners took off
his clothes and threw them on her. We felt deeply humiliated, even
more than she felt, because the only thing we could do is to put our
heads down.
There was a young man of 35 with me in the tent, F says. He was
very polite, handsome and religious. One day the called him for
investigation, he disappeared for many days, when he came back he was
a different man. He told us that a female American soldier found him
handsome as she said and wanted to have a boy from him. She took off
her clothes and tried to sleep with him. He refused. She tied his
eyes, pulled him naked from a sensitive part of his body and took him
somewhere. She made him go around in some place , she walked him for
about 50 meters, then she removed the tie from his eyes, he found
himself in the middle of women prison where many women prisoners were
naked too. He saw a very old woman sitting there with her head down.
The female soldier told him that there are cameras in the place. He
was left in this situation for 17 days.
Prisoner F demanded that all soldiers who leave Iraq should be
searched for videos and photos, which prove that they came to
humiliate us.
Another prisoner who was released in February 2004, again refused to
give his name or any details about his arrest until he reached Abu
Graib, told us that while he was taken from one place to another, the
American soldier pushed me to the ground, put his boot on my neck and
pulled up my head. He removed the sack from my head and told me to
look. I saw two women in a truck, they looked like a mother and a
daughter. It was raining heavily. The younger was barefoot. I cried
that night, I was a prisoner, tied I could not defend our women.
During the investigation, this man said, the American soldier asked me
about my childhood, if I was sexually abused, if I had sex with
animals, then he asked me how I found him, and asked to look in his
eyes. I told him that I was a Moslem, that I pray and fast , that I am
a grandfather, I do not care about anything , only my granddaughter.
He made fun of me, and asked if my wife was beautiful, then he spit on
the ground and left the room. In another prison, an old bearded man of
65 years told me that he was asked the same questions, then the
officer offered to bring his wife and daughter to the prison. The old
man spit in the officer's face, He was crying , praying all the time
never talked or said anything after that.
A
prisoner who spent 67 days in Um Qasr detention camp deep in the
south, said that there were 3 tents for children, juvenile, and women
prisoners. He said that he was beaten cruelly when he saw a girl of 12
being investigated, he was so mad that he began to shout Is this the
freedom that the American promised us. A human rights representative
in the American Army, replied Freedom is for the Americans, not for
the Iraqis.
From
all the stories above, and many others, it is obvious that women are
used as a material and means of violations. She is used against man.
Using the value of honor in its eastern, Arabic and Islamic context
means that these kinds of abuses are built on the psychological and
cultural structures of the Iraqi society. They are meant to break the
Iraqi's image of himself, women's image in society and to herself
occupationwatcheman@yahoo.com.